Indianapolis — the Crossroads of America — has a church scene that's as unpretentious and welcoming as the city itself. Indy may not get the attention of coastal cities, but its faith community is deep, genuine, and growing. From nationally recognized megachurches on the north side to historic congregations downtown and revitalizing church plants on the east side, Indianapolis offers a remarkably complete church landscape. Whether you're cheering for the Colts or attending the 500, you'll find a church family here that feels like home. Also exploring Midwestern cities? Check out our guides to Columbus and Fort Worth, or see what's happening on the coast in Seattle.

1. Traders Point Christian Church

Christian Church

Traders Point Christian Church is one of Indianapolis's most dynamic congregations, with multiple campuses across the metro. Their main campus in Whitestown features stunning architecture with a barn-inspired design that reflects Indiana's agricultural heritage. The teaching is practical and Scripture-driven, the worship is contemporary and engaging, and their children's ministry is among the best in the state. The church's commitment to community impact — including their "For Our Neighbor" initiative — demonstrates faith in action.

Overall Rating	4.8 / 5
Teaching	4.8 / 5
Children's Ministry	4.9 / 5
Welcome	4.8 / 5

📍 9950 E 156th St, Noblesville, IN 46060

View Full Profile →

2. Northview Church

Non-Denominational

Northview Church in Carmel has established itself as one of the premier churches on the north side of Indianapolis. With a large, welcoming campus and a strong emphasis on life groups, Northview creates community at scale. The preaching is consistently solid — Biblical, practical, and delivered with Midwestern warmth. Their missions program is extensive, and the church has a genuine heart for serving both the local community and the global church.

Overall Rating	4.8 / 5
Community	4.8 / 5
Teaching	4.8 / 5
Worship	4.7 / 5

📍 12900 Hazel Dell Pkwy, Carmel, IN 46033

View Full Profile →

3. College Park Church

Non-Denominational

College Park Church on the north side of Indianapolis is known for its exceptional expository preaching. If you're looking for a church where the sermon is the centerpiece and the Bible is opened deeply every week, College Park delivers. The congregation is theologically serious but warmly welcoming, and their elder-led governance model creates stability and accountability. A favorite among seminary students, pastors, and anyone who values doctrinal depth.

Overall Rating	4.8 / 5
Teaching	4.9 / 5
Community	4.7 / 5
Worship	4.7 / 5

📍 2606 W 96th St, Indianapolis, IN 46268

View Full Profile →

4. Eastern Star Church

Baptist

Eastern Star Church under the leadership of Senior Pastor Jeffrey Johnson is one of the largest and most influential African American congregations in Indianapolis. Located on the east side of the city, Eastern Star is known for powerful preaching, spirit-filled worship, and a comprehensive approach to community development that includes economic empowerment, educational programs, and health initiatives. This church doesn't just preach transformation — it lives it.

Overall Rating	4.7 / 5
Teaching	4.8 / 5
Community	4.8 / 5
Worship	4.8 / 5

📍 5750 E 30th St, Indianapolis, IN 46218

View Full Profile →

5. SS. Peter and Paul Cathedral

Catholic

The Cathedral of Saints Peter and Paul on Meridian Street is the mother church of the Archdiocese of Indianapolis and one of the most beautiful sacred spaces in the Midwest. The Romanesque architecture, stunning stained glass, and reverent liturgy create a worship experience that feels transcendent. Located just north of downtown, the cathedral draws a diverse congregation and offers multiple Mass times throughout the week.

Overall Rating	4.7 / 5
Worship	4.9 / 5
Teaching	4.7 / 5
Welcome	4.6 / 5

📍 1347 N Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46202

View Full Profile →

6. Zionsville Fellowship Church

Non-Denominational

Zionsville Fellowship serves the charming village of Zionsville on the northwest side of the metro with a warm, family-oriented community. The teaching is solidly evangelical, the worship strikes a nice balance between traditional and contemporary, and the church has a genuine small-town feel despite being part of a rapidly growing suburb. Their youth ministry is particularly strong, and the church is deeply embedded in the Zionsville community.

Overall Rating	4.7 / 5
Children's Ministry	4.8 / 5
Community	4.8 / 5
Welcome	4.7 / 5

📍 Zionsville, IN

View Full Profile →

7. Redeemer Presbyterian Church

Presbyterian (PCA)

Redeemer Presbyterian on the near north side brings a Reformed, gospel-centered approach to Indianapolis. Influenced by the broader Redeemer movement, this church combines theological depth with a heart for the city. The teaching is intellectually rich, the community is engaged in neighborhood renewal, and the worship blends traditional hymns with modern arrangements. A great fit for those who want their faith to be both thoughtful and active.

Overall Rating	4.6 / 5
Teaching	4.8 / 5
Community	4.7 / 5
Worship	4.6 / 5

📍 Near North Side, Indianapolis, IN

View Full Profile →

8. First Baptist Church of Indianapolis

Baptist

First Baptist Church on North Delaware Street has been a landmark of downtown Indianapolis since 1822. This historic congregation has adapted beautifully to the modern era while maintaining the rich traditions that have sustained it for two centuries. The choir is magnificent, the preaching is grounded and passionate, and the church's commitment to serving downtown Indianapolis through outreach ministries is inspiring.

Overall Rating	4.6 / 5
Worship	4.8 / 5
Teaching	4.7 / 5
Community	4.6 / 5

📍 8600 N College Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46240

View Full Profile →

9. Brookside Community Church

Non-Denominational

Brookside Community Church on the east side of Indianapolis represents the best of the urban church plant movement. Meeting in a revitalized neighborhood, Brookside is committed to being a church for the community, not just in it. The teaching is honest and practical, the worship is intimate, and the community is diverse in every way — racially, economically, and generationally. If you want to be part of a church that's genuinely making a difference, Brookside is it.

Overall Rating	4.6 / 5
Community	4.8 / 5
Welcome	4.8 / 5
Teaching	4.6 / 5

📍 East Side, Indianapolis, IN

View Full Profile →

10. Second Presbyterian Church

Presbyterian

Second Presbyterian Church on Meridian Street is one of Indianapolis's most architecturally impressive churches, with a Gothic Revival sanctuary that houses magnificent Tiffany stained-glass windows. The congregation values intellectual engagement, beautiful worship, and community service. Their music program is outstanding, and the church offers a range of educational opportunities for adults. A cornerstone of the Meridian-Kessler neighborhood and Indianapolis's mainline Protestant tradition.

Overall Rating	4.6 / 5
Worship	4.8 / 5
Teaching	4.7 / 5
Welcome	4.5 / 5

📍 7700 N Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46260

View Full Profile →

How We Ranked These Churches

Our rankings are based on FaithScout's multi-dimensional rating system. Unlike simple star ratings, we evaluate churches across five key dimensions that matter most to visitors: teaching quality, community atmosphere, worship experience, welcome and hospitality, and children's ministry. Each score comes directly from real visitor reports — not paid placements or self-reported data.

Churches are ranked by their overall composite score, weighted by the number of visitor reviews. For Indianapolis, we represented the full spectrum of the city — from north side megachurches to downtown cathedrals, east side community churches, and suburban congregations — to help you find the right fit wherever you live.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best church in Indianapolis?

Based on visitor ratings on FaithScout, Traders Point Christian Church, Northview Church, and College Park Church are among the highest-rated congregations in Indianapolis. The best church for you depends on your preferences — take the FaithScout quiz to find your ideal match.

Are there megachurches in Indianapolis?

Yes, Indianapolis has several large, multi-campus churches including Traders Point Christian Church, Northview Church, and College Park Church, each drawing thousands of attendees weekly. These churches offer extensive programming, professional-quality worship, and comprehensive children's ministries.

What is the church culture like in Indianapolis?

Indianapolis has a warm, Midwestern church culture that's genuinely welcoming to newcomers. The city sits at the crossroads of Southern hospitality and Midwestern friendliness, creating congregations that are approachable, community-minded, and unpretentious. Don't be surprised if someone invites you to lunch after your first visit.

Are there diverse churches in Indianapolis?

Yes, Indianapolis has a growing number of multiethnic congregations, along with historically Black churches like Eastern Star Church, Latino congregations, and Burmese Christian communities reflecting the city's significant refugee resettlement efforts. Brookside Community Church and Transformation Church are known for their diverse congregations.

How do I find the right church in Indianapolis?

Take FaithScout's free 2-minute quiz at faithscout.com/onboarding to get personalized church recommendations based on your preferences. You can also browse all Indianapolis churches and filter by denomination, worship style, and location.

Start Your Church Search in Indianapolis

Indianapolis may be known as the Crossroads of America, but it's also a crossroads of faith traditions — where Midwestern warmth meets deep theological conviction and genuine community. Whether you're drawn to the family-friendly campuses of Traders Point, the doctrinal depth of College Park, or the urban impact of Brookside Community, Indy has a church that will welcome you with open arms.

Ready to find yours? Take the FaithScout quiz to get personalized matches, or browse all Indianapolis churches to explore on your own. Also check out our guides to Columbus and Charlotte for more great church recommendations.